Wednesday, 16 March 2011

We Can't COPE If Everyone Is Yelling

It finally happened. With all the inevitability of another Rocky movie, the Spanish media have once again upped the stakes. This time it was the Madrid based radio station Cadena COPE that broke the story that Real Madrid have requested stricter doping regulations from the Spanish FA (RFEF). The inference is that other clubs are benefiting from using performance enhancing drugs. And when we talk about Real Madrid and other clubs all we really mean is Barcelona. Although Valencia have also been implicated, the major target seems to be the Pep and his Golden Boys. COPE’s story was in essence a circumspect accusation that Barcelona has been doping it’s players.

Both Barca and Valencia have of course denied this very strongly and unless COPE or Real Madrid have any evidence then the story is likely to die here. Despite controversy surrounding both Spanish cyclists and athletes, it seems more than a little far-fetched that the players of either club have deliberately taken banned substances. Mundo Deportivo and Sport (two Barcelona-supporting papers) have declared their outrage and accused Florentino Perez and Jose Mourinho of creating this smear campaign against the Catalan club.

Now while it would make me feel better to know that Leo Messi is actually a drug-fuelled monstrosity whose skill comes in easy-to-swallow pill form, it doesn’t seem likely. In any case it would probably constitute the first time ever that a club had given players drugs to make them shorter. The more surprising fact is that it’s taken this long to get to this point. AS, Mundo Deportivo, Marca and all the other Spanish sports papers have been building this war for years. Cristiano Ronaldo has been awarded by goals by Marca that even the RFEF has declared an own goal in the papers manic drive to see the Portuguese forward given the Pichichi (top scorer) over Messi. They also feature a “corrected” table which is supposed to represent what the table would look like if all refereeing decisions were 100% right. Guess what, Madrid are only one point behind as opposed to seven. But wait, Barcelona had a legitimate goal disallowed against Sevilla last weekend. Did Marca give Barcelona an additional two points which they would have gotten with correct decision? Take a guess. The other major Madrid daily AS actually went as far as to photoshop Athletic Bilbao defender Koikili out of a picture to try and show Dani Alves as offside in the build up to Barcelona’s opening goal.

Both sides are so virulent in their attacks on the enemy that it wasn’t long before one side would accuse the other of doping. After all they both accuse each other of bribing the referees and other clubs of not trying. Although he was talking about the much more serious issue of the Gabrielle Giffords shooting in Tucson, Arizona Slate’s John Dickerson was 100% right when he said that if “Everyone [in the media] is already supercharged and yelling then nobody is going to listen, they’ll just yell louder.”

I don’t wish to cheapen the events in Tucson, but the point is still relevant. The dailies in Spain are so partisan, so biased and so crazed that facts are being jettisoned in any situation they don’t support the arguments being made. In such an atmosphere, it was inevitable that the issues of bribery or doping would eventually be brought up. The best that can be hoped for is that the threat of legal action preserves a tiny bit of sanity. But as the stakes between the two giants continue to rise, the chances are that more stories like this will emerge, casting sleaze over some of the best football the world has ever seen.

Monday, 14 March 2011

Been There, Read That, Bought The Narrative

In football there are some certainties that crop up as sure as night follows day. Sepp Blatter will continue to act like a complete clown, guzzling free champagne while bringing the game into disrepute through his disgusting incompetence and corruption do a sterling job to promote the beautiful game in all countries, working hard for the betterment of mankind through football. Referees will continue to be insulted and attacked despite doing a very necessary and important job by managers seeking an easy target. The duopoly in Spain will continue to grow until the entire planet serves as the footballing equivalent of salt mines for our new Iberian overlords.

The latest addition to these certainties is that any tie between Manchester United and Manchester City will be represented as a “potential shift in power in Manchester” by the media. Much like the other inevitabilities in football, forcing every Manchester derby into the same narrative is immensely tiresome and silly.

Manchester City are undeniably a club on the rise. Barring an extraordinary end to the season they will be in the Champions League next year. But a power shift is not something that happens on the basis of one game except in very unique circumstances. Beating United and then potentially Bolton or Stoke to win their first trophy in 35 years would be a big step forward for the Blues. Yes, United have vast mountains of debt and some key players on the verge of retirement, not to mention the inevitable retirement of Sir Alex Ferguson one day.

But the same United are top of the league, have just beaten their closest rivals in the FA Cup and are in a reasonably strong position to make it into the Champions League quarter-finals. So even if Manchester City rise to the point where they are serious title challengers year on year it doesn’t mean that they will actually supplant United merely that they will become rivals for trophies.

The problem is that all of this has been said before. Every single time the two clubs play these days the cliché about power shifting is trotted out as though it represents an analysis of what this game means. We know that Manchester City are on the rise. It doesn’t need to be said every single time they play United. Please, just give it a rest.

The fact is that the narrative is too good to be ignored because it fits any circumstance. If United dominate then they have “sent a message” but if their lucky then its “experience and the sign of champions”. Meanwhile any City victory will be greeted with “the real arrival of the Abu Dhabi revolution”. Whoever wins out of the pair, it doesn’t need to be played out as “a reassertion of dominance” or “uppity neighbours challenge status quo”. Sometimes a game is just a game and it would be nice to enjoy it without a tired and familiar media narrative being dusted off weeks in advance.